There are mostly quite a few differences in plot between twelfth night and shes the man. That makes shakespeare the most filmed playwright of all time. The movie also had the advantage of including scenery and more props that enhanced the performance. Twelfth night 1996 is a modern film adaptation of one of shakespeares comedy plays, directed by trevor nunn. Cartoon shakespeare offers twelfth night the comic book by artist john howard. Christensen sebastian madame tusk antonio, a sea captain, friend to sebastian alan davis drake a sea captain kara. Comparing twelfth night and shes the man english literature essay.
This twelfth night study guide is aimed at students of gcse media studies and english and. Scenes from twelfth night by william shakespeare with study. Disguise and jealousy, love and appearance versus reality. Twelfth night is an ok shakespeare adaptation, a handsome. Twelfth night, shes the man shes the man is a loosely based modernized version of the famous shakespeare play, twelfth night.
One summer in the 1980s, hugh and olivia crain buy hill house to flip for profit, moving in with their. Girl is in disguise as her twin brother for her own reasons, which evolves into a distorted love triangle. Here are the best, and most noteworthy, versions of twelfth night that can help you study and better understand the play. Twelfth night essay twelfth night is a comedy and a marvel. This play conveys many messages that are seen by the audience, but not seen by the characters in the play. However, at the time of this movie s release, imogen stubbs viola was thirtyfive. Twelfth night has been directed by trevor nunn, for 20 years a stalwart of the royal shakespeare company. He knows the material, and knows the right actors to play it. The play centers on the twins viola and sebastian, who are separated in a shipwreck. What is the difference between the film twelfth night and the play twelfth night. It also, illustrates the change in feminine roles in the community and society at large, the main theme of the movie being feminism. What is the difference between the film twelfth night and the. Film upon seeing the film i did notice some similarities and differences between my interpretation of the characters and the filmmakers. However, one other significant difference from play to film is that nunn chose not to elucidate the homoerotic elements in twelfth night.
An ideal introduction before reading the original text. List of william shakespeare screen adaptations wikipedia. The theme of madness in twelfth night often overlaps the themes of desire and love. The following film notes were prepared for the new york state writers institute by kevin jack hagopian, senior lecturer in media studies at pennsylvania state. Free kindle book and epub digitized and proofread by project gutenberg. The first main one is one similar to the theme of donnes the flea and marvells to his coy mistress. Mind that the sample papers like twelfth night comparitive essay. William shakespeare 15641616 shakespeares great festive comedy, probably written and first performed around 1601, follows the adventures of twins viola and sebastian, who are separated from each other by a shipwreck. Twelfth night or what you will 1996 twelfth night or what. The differences among the play and movie become clear through these two versions of twelfth night. Shakespeares twelfth night essay, summary, quotes and. This is a digital copy of a book that was preserved for. Some are born great, some achieve greatness and some have greatness thrust upon them. What are differences and similarities between shakespeare.
While the nunn movie goes for broad comedy and slapstick, the branagh version is more pensive and moody. So are other kinds of love, like friendship and the love between siblings. Every book on your english syllabus summed up in a quote from the office. Mary piphers bestselling 1994 book reviving ophelia brought these discourses to. The play has been transformed into multiple movie versions including a bbc version, hollywood version and a modern version called shes the man. Twelfth night, or what you will is a romantic comedy by william shakespeare, believed to have been written around 16011602 as a twelfth nights entertainment for the close of the christmas season. My point is that a director of authentic genius is necessary to make a satisfactory transfer of shakespeare into a film. The name twelfth night has no particular connection to the events in the play.
The biggest difference is that amanda byness character, viola, decides to impersonate her brother at his. Twelfth night cliffsnotes study guides book summaries. The movie shes the man shows much of the general idea of the original shakespearean book, the twelfth night. Twelfth night, or what you will themes art and culture in twelfth night, shakespeare explores the workings of the theater and other related forms of artistic performance licensed fooling, music, and singing, which also happen to be forms of revelry associated with the twelfth night festivities for which the play is named. Jul 12, 2012 this is mainly because the movie had different actors for every part so you could understand who it is and what they were doing. A short summary of william shakespeares twelfth night. Hidden and mistaken identities, requited and unrequited loves, pranks and jokes abound in this romantic comedy. The two titles are better then the other in different ways and both appeal to separate audiences. Both poems have somewhat carpe diem ideas, using ridiculous excuses or reasoning to try to get the woman to sleep with them. Twelfth night is set in in illyria, a real place from classical antiquity, that existed as far back as the tenth century b. The film version is by merchant ivory productions and the live version is performed by the bell shakespeare company.
The most obvious is antonios morethanfriendly feeling. I would really recommend this book for people studying the actual script and want a better understanding or just show a general interest in the play. These differences include in the movie the story was better explained, which make it more understandable and enjoyable. Aug 08, 2002 twelfth night is my favourite shakespeare play and i really enjoyed this version. Orsino talks about the faculty of love producing multiple changing images of the beloved, similar to hallucinations. Heres where youll find analysis about the play as a whole, from the major. A mix of tartuffe and miss trunchbull tamsin greig as malvolia right, with doon mackichan as feste, in twelfth night at the olivier, london.
In twelfth night, the character of orsino is several years older than viola. This free synopsis covers all the crucial plot points of twelfth night. The new title implies that the movie will be more of a comedy, while the title twelfth night doesnt really imply that the play will be a comedy at all, but more in the tragedy genre. After the twins sebastian and viola survive a shipwreck, neither knows that the other is alive. Created using powtoon free sign up at youtube create animated videos and animated presentations for free. Read a plot overview of the entire play or a scene by scene summary and analysis. The name likely comes from a performance of the play twelve days after christmas, on the feast of the epiphany, possibly at whitehall palace in 1602. Or what you will is a 1996 britishamericanirish film adaptation of william shakespeares play, directed by trevor nunn and featuring an allstar cast. The above considerations are not intended to blame twelfth night, a pleasant movie with some merits.
Nov 21, 2014 t opnotch productions of shakespeares greatest comedy have been a bit thin on the ground lately. The mood of twelfth night certainly suits the occasion. Twelfth night an allusion to the night of festivity preceding the christian celebration of the epiphanycombines love, confusion, mistaken identities, and joyful discovery. Twelfth night by william shakespeare free at loyal books. What is the difference between the film twelfth night and.
Twelfth night, or what you will introduction shmoop. The first thing that caught me off guard was the portrayal of cesario viola. The film was directed by andy fickman and stars amanda bynes and channing tatum. During shakespeares time, the area, off the adriatic sea, was.
While reading i could be as imaginative as possible, thus giving the character of. I loved that it wasnt written like a play but like a story so it helped me with my understanding of the script. Get an answer for what are some of the differences between the film and the text of twelfth night. In shes the man, its malcolm feste, and in twelfth night. What are differences and similarities between shakespeares.
There are many points involving love, friendship, conflicts and confusion. Nov 28, 2017 created using powtoon free sign up at youtube create animated videos and animated presentations for free. Twelfth night displays characters that are mad, in love, and desperate for love. Comparing shes the man to twelfth night by jun wu on prezi. Twelfth night was first adapted into a film in 1910, as a silent production. The guinness book of records lists 410 featurelength film and tv versions of william shakespeare s plays, making shakespeare the most filmed author ever in any language as of july 2018, the internet movie database lists shakespeare as having writing credit on 1,371 films, including those under production but not yet released. Comparing twelfth night to shes the man theme of love both twelfth night and shes the man have the same theme of love where the main characters are connected in a love triangle. The arden shakespeare series are the best commentry on shakespeare around. One last example is that olivia has a man trying to woo her in both the play and movie. Shakespeares comedy of gender confusion, in which a girl disguises herself as a man to be near the count she adores, only to be pursued by the woman he loves. Get an answer for what are differences and similarities between shakespeares twelfth night and the movie shes the man. The earliest known production is king john from 1899. Shakespeares language is not hard to understand when spoken by actors who are comfortable with the rhythm and know the meaning. Adaptations of shakespeares plays and other works have been featured in nearly 500 films andor videos worldwide.
However, jonathan munbys version, for english touring theatre and sheffield theatres, is up. Or, what you will trevor nunns popular 1996 film stars imogen stubbs viola, helena bonham carter olivia, and ben kingsley feste. Twelfth night by andrew matthews goodreads share book. Upon seeing the film i did notice some similarities and differences between my interpretation of the characters and the filmmakers. If the entire film had held the rich and buoyant quality of the final reels. Master shakespeares twelfth night using absolute shakespeares twelfth night essay, plot summary, quotes and characters study guides. If youre studying twelfth night for exams, coursework or for performance either directing or performing, then this book will be essential to get the best from the play. The film of twelfth night has been directed by trevor nunn. See a complete list of the characters in twelfth night and indepth analyses of viola, orsino and olivia, malvolio, sebastian, and antonio. Hollywood shakespeare released on a movie called twelfth night which is an adaptation of shakespeares comedy twelfth night and its hilario. Twelfth night comparison essay twelfth night is written by william shakespeare. What are some of the differences between the film and the text of.
1533 958 912 40 954 1137 1321 441 371 881 348 929 180 171 733 676 854 1325 696 469 1198 39 1260 786 1400 240 766 185 1135 733 238 49 1333 458 573